With over 740 episodes of brotherly chaos under their belts, Justin, Travis, and Griffin McElroy have created countless memorable moments in “My Brother, My Brother and Me.” From haunted dolls to questionable fast food innovations, choosing the best episodes feels a bit like picking favorite children – if those children were filled with bizarre Yahoo Answers questions and tangents about horses.
But fear not, sweet babies: whether you’re a longtime listener looking to revisit some classics or a newcomer wondering where to dive into this comedy treasure trove, I’ve rounded up the episodes that best showcase the McElroys’ unique blend of terrible advice and impeccable comedic timing.
389: Horsebonology
Listen on: Episodes.fm | Apple Podcasts | Spotify | Overcast
In this fever-dream of an episode, the brothers uncover disturbing truths about nature’s finest creature, all while navigating the delirious effects of heavy-duty cold medication. Consider this your trial by fire – only the brave should proceed.
461: All Rise
Listen on: Episodes.fm | Apple Podcasts | Spotify | Overcast
The brothers kick off this episode by hyping up the year’s upcoming TV lineup before pitching their latest million-dollar idea: a food delivery service that morphs into a weapon-toting monster. Hollywood executives, the ball’s in their court.
535: Ethical Joker Termination
Listen on: Episodes.fm | Apple Podcasts | Spotify | Overcast
The brothers tackle the ultimate comic book conundrum in this episode, debating how to deal with Gotham’s most notorious troublemaker without crossing any moral lines – though their proposed solutions might suggest otherwise. Between defending Bruce Wayne’s honor and workshopping creative takedown strategies, they discover there just might be an ethical way to neutralize the Clown Prince of Crime after all.
207: Thank Travis for Travis
Listen on: Episodes.fm | Apple Podcasts | Spotify | Overcast
Riding a wave of post-dental surgery painkillers, Justin joins his brothers for a uniquely loopy episode, while Travis debuts his self-penned spiritual anthem.
514: Kickeo
Listen on: Episodes.fm | Apple Podcasts | Spotify | Overcast
Looking to hire former WWE superstar Dave Bautista for some completely justified home demolition? The brothers crunch the numbers and discover that property destruction by a Hollywood action hero might just fit your budget.
394: Face 2 Face: I Fritos Hard
Listen on: Episodes.fm | Apple Podcasts | Spotify | Overcast
The brothers present a spicy live recording from Milwaukee, where despite their collective ailments, they delivered an unexpectedly flirtatious performance. This throwback episode steps in while Justin enjoys some quality time with his newest family member.
254: Dunkey
Listen on: Episodes.fm | Apple Podcasts | Spotify | Overcast
The brothers propose a radical national rebrand, suggesting it’s time for America to evolve from its basic form into something more spectacular – all while channeling the spirit of everyone’s favorite animated troublemaker.
104: I Hate You, Ron
Listen on: Episodes.fm | Apple Podcasts | Spotify | Overcast
Despite a week of major headlines, the brothers steer clear of any serious analysis, reminding listeners that they’re comedians, not political commentators – and certainly not known for their deep insights into current events.
400: The Escape to Margaritaville Red Carpet Extravaganza
Listen on: Episodes.fm | Apple Podcasts | Spotify | Overcast
The hosts acknowledge their complete ineptitude in two areas: interacting normally with celebrities and basic social engagement with any human being. This context becomes particularly relevant as they recount their experience recording their 400th episode from the red carpet of Jimmy Buffett’s Escape to Margaritaville Broadway premiere. While enduring playful mockery from various celebrities who easily dissect their show’s shortcomings, they remind listeners that it’s MaxFunDrive season and suggest that supporting their unique journalistic approach could help soothe their wounded pride.
215: Glass Shark
Listen on: Episodes.fm | Apple Podcasts | Spotify | Overcast
The hosts have returned, though their performance is somewhat debatable. By their own estimation, they’re maintaining their usual standards, though with some caveats: Justin appears to be out of practice, Griffin is experiencing a mild slump, and Travis’s audio quality suggests he may have utilized antiquated recording equipment. Nevertheless, they’ve managed to resume their usual programming.
500: Spaghettageddon Two: 2 Saucy, 2 Carbious
Listen on: Episodes.fm | Apple Podcasts | Spotify | Overcast
The hosts warn listeners that their pasta-consumption capabilities have evolved significantly over the past decade. While recording together with their families, they delivered spontaneous songs and engaged in athletic competition. They express deep gratitude for their audience’s decade-long support and its life-changing impact, choosing to commemorate this milestone by consuming excessive amounts of pasta on recording.
151: Orb is Horse
Listen on: Episodes.fm | Apple Podcasts | Spotify | Overcast
The hosts could barely contain their enthusiasm for the Kentucky Derby. They revered this celebration of equine excellence – a showcase of elite specimens from what they already considered to be nature’s most magnificent creatures.
448: Bird Words
Listen on: Episodes.fm | Apple Podcasts | Spotify | Overcast
The hosts deliver what might be the most specialized content ever produced, specifically targeting an extremely niche audience: students scrambling to complete their ornithological assignments before the next school day.
240: Teen Google
Listen on: Episodes.fm | Apple Podcasts | Spotify | Overcast
The hosts bid farewell to their audience, claiming that their newfound extreme wealth has rendered them incapable of maintaining regular employment. They humorously suggest that their excessive displays of affluence – specifically, the continuous tossing of currency – interfere with their recording capabilities.
547: Chili Wonka
Listen on: Episodes.fm | Apple Podcasts | Spotify | Overcast
A pivotal moment emerges quietly. An innocuous online query sparks a cultural schism that will shape an era. The transformation of bathwater into broth becomes an inescapable truth. The implications of this knowledge rest solely with its recipients.
396: Independence Jumanji 3
Listen on: Episodes.fm | Apple Podcasts | Spotify | Overcast
The hosts celebrate cinema’s grandest evening (a title they insist remains valid). They deliver their signature warped humor while commenting on the major films and various proceedings from this most prestigious of Hollywood gatherings.
528: The War With Grandpa Watch
Listen on: Episodes.fm | Apple Podcasts | Spotify | Overcast
I won’t spoil ANYTHING about this episode. Just go listen to it.
341: An Erotic Balloon Puzzle
Listen on: Episodes.fm | Apple Podcasts | Spotify | Overcast
The hosts offer commentary on the much-anticipated championship game and its associated events. With playful skepticism, they question whether the “Super” designation was truly merited. They acknowledge the predictable nature of their humor about this topic while presenting it regardless.
447: Valentine’s Escape Room
Listen on: Episodes.fm | Apple Podcasts | Spotify | Overcast
It’s a Valentine’s Day special. You’ll love this episode.
597: Foy’s Boys
Listen on: Episodes.fm | Apple Podcasts | Spotify | Overcast
The hosts attempt to return to their standard format, apparently believing this requires increased discussion of athletics. They welcome specialist contributor Ify Nwadiwe, who shares his distinct insights on Taco Bell’s breakfast drink selection and the curious eyewear-cleaning services at Disney theme parks.
432: Hand Dog and Face Cat
Listen on: Episodes.fm | Apple Podcasts | Spotify | Overcast
A moment of reckoning has arrived. Everyone must now choose between two unsettling, consciousness-corrupting pets that threaten to drag their households toward damnation. The gravity of this selection cannot be understated. Trust one’s inner guidance.
259: Birthday Surprise Hole
Listen on: Episodes.fm | Apple Podcasts | Spotify | Overcast
The hosts explain that despite their planned content, they abandoned their usual format shortly after beginning. This unique episode instead evolved into a session of retrospective guidance, offering wisdom to their younger selves – including stern warnings about questionable hair styling choices.
259: Birthday Surprise Hole
Listen on: Episodes.fm | Apple Podcasts | Spotify | Overcast
The hosts explain that despite their planned content, they abandoned their usual format shortly after beginning. This unique episode instead evolved into a session of retrospective guidance, offering wisdom to their younger selves – including stern warnings about questionable hair styling choices.
351: Omnidirectional Scampi Blast
Listen on: Episodes.fm | Apple Podcasts | Spotify | Overcast
The hosts commemorate a significant anniversary by sacrificing a Razor Scooter to an active volcano’s depths. They also dedicate almost an hour to an extensive appreciation of garlicky shrimp pasta.
Read our review of My Brother, My Brother & Me
Discover other podcasts like My Brother, My Brother & Me