Skip to main content
Best Podcasts

Best Mystery Podcasts

Best Mystery Podcasts

Let’s take an audio tour of the thrilling world of unsolved mysteries, and spine-chilling tales with our curated list of the best mystery podcasts. Whether you’re a seasoned sleuth or new to the genre, these audio experiences will light up your imagination and keep you on the edge of your seat. 

From cold cases and paranormal investigations to fictional narratives that blur the lines between reality and fantasy, I’ve scoured the podcast landscape to bring you a selection that covers every facet of the mystery realm. Get ready to turn up the volume and embark on a journey through the unknown.

Limetown

Limetown

Listen to Limetown

A decade past, an entire community vanished without a trace from a tiny Tennessee village, leaving no clues behind. This podcast follows the investigation of Lia Haddock, an American Public Radio journalist, as she delves into the enduring mystery: “Where did Limetown’s residents go?”

Strange and Unexplained with Daisy Eagan

Strange and Unexplained with Daisy Eagan

Listen to Strange and Unexplained with Daisy Eagan

An audio series exploring enigmatic and perplexing phenomena. Every episode presents a factual narrative designed to intrigue and unsettle: a household plagued by an anonymous observer, a seemingly ill-fated lodging with a dark history, encounters with unidentified flying objects, ghostly occurrences, alleged sightings of cryptids, and numerous other mysteries.

The Deca Tapes

Listen to The Deca Tapes

A narrative enigma unfolds across eight installments. Audio evidence has emerged featuring ten individuals confined within a shared environment. Their location remains unknown, as does their fate. Yet, within these recordings lie the clues to unraveling the puzzle.

Solve This Murder

Listen to Solve This Murder

Join forces with Bill as he gathers evidence and questions persons of interest to crack freshly-crafted homicide puzzles!

Scary Mysteries

Listen to Scary Mysteries

This podcast explores a wide array of intriguing and unsettling topics. It talks about real-life criminal cases, eerie collections of stories, and perplexing enigmas. The show’s content spans from homicide investigations and unexplained disappearances to discussions of historical locations, cryptozoological beings, and paranormal phenomena. It aims to satisfy listeners’ curiosity for the strange and unexplained across various subjects.

Your Own Backyard

Listen to Your Own Backyard

An investigative audio series examining the unsolved vanishing of Kristin Smart, a college student from Cal Poly, in 1996.

Unfound

Unfound

Listen to Unfound

Launched in the fall of 2016, this podcast spotlights unexplained disappearances by conversing with those intimately connected to each case – loved ones, acquaintances, and journalists. The show’s primary goal is to uncover fresh information that could propel stalled investigations.

Unexplained

Unexplained

Listen to Unexplained

This bi-weekly audio series explores the perplexing and eerie true-life occurrences that defy rational explanation. Blending storytelling, historical context, and thought-provoking concepts – often with chilling results – the show navigates the murky waters between perceived reality and the unknown. It explores realms where conviction can be as tangible as what we consider “real,” whatever that may truly mean.

Unexplained Encounters

Unexplained Encounters

Listen to Unexplained Encounters

Narrator Darkness Prevails presents “Unexplained Encounters,” an audio series featuring ordinary individuals recounting their most chilling and bewildering experiences. From enigmatic beings spotted in wilderness areas to paranormal occurrences upending daily lives, listeners are invited to explore the realm of the inexplicable. While these tales may seem far-fetched, the audience is left to determine which accounts they find credible.

All Things Unexplained

All Things Unexplained

Listen to All Things Unexplained

This podcast is a weekly audio and visual program, releasing fresh content each Monday. This series interrogates a spectrum of puzzling subjects, ranging from extraterrestrial phenomena and cryptozoological entities to the complexities of celestial physics, encompassing a wide array of intriguing themes.

Hey Riddle Riddle

Hey Riddle Riddle

Listen to Hey Riddle Riddle

Conundrums! Brain-teasers! Mystery-solvers! Three Chicago-based comedians of questionable renown – Adal Rifai, Erin Keif, and John Patrick Coan – take on the challenge of cracking every enigma, mind-bender, and perplexing problem known to humankind. The difficulty ranges from the nearly unsolvable to the utterly absurd, with a few that have lost their relevance over time.

CBS Radio Mystery Theater

CBS Radio Mystery Theater

Listen to CBS Radio Mystery Theater

From 1974 to 1982, a radio drama series known as the “CBS Radio Mystery Theater” (sometimes shortened to CBSRMT) aired on CBS Radio Network stations. The program was the brainchild of producer Himan Brown. In the early 2000s, it found new life on NPR’s satellite broadcast. The show’s structure echoed classic radio dramas such as “The Mysterious Traveler” and “The Whistler.” Each episode featured a narrator (E. G. Marshall) who introduced the story and offered insightful commentary throughout the broadcast.

Passenger List

Passenger List

Listen to Passenger List

A transatlantic airliner, Flight 702, vanishes without a trace while en route from London to New York, carrying 256 souls. Among those searching for answers is Kaitlin Le (portrayed by Kelly Marie Tran), a university student whose sibling – her twin brother – was aboard the missing aircraft. Driven by personal stakes, Kaitlin embarks on a quest to unveil the mystery surrounding the plane’s disappearance.

All Aussie Mystery Hour

All Aussie Mystery Hour

Listen to All Aussie Mystery Hour

Every installment features Pedestrian’s devoted true crime enthusiasts Josie and Mel presenting a unique unsolved Australian enigma. They share their often outlandish hypotheses about what might have transpired. The cases range from the vanishing of the Beaumont Children to sightings of the elusive Lithgow Panther and the perplexing Somerton Man incident. Each mystery seems to surpass the previous one in its level of bizarreness.

The Strange and Unusual Podcast

The Strange and Unusual Podcast

Listen to The Strange and Unusual Podcast

Uncertainty forms the foundation of all dread, spawning myths, beliefs, traditions, cultural practices, mass panic, and even violent acts throughout human history. The echoes of our forebears’ attempts to comprehend the enigmatic continue to resonate in nearly every aspect of modern life. Be it through religious doctrines, contemporary folklore, popular media, tales of spectral encounters, or ritualistic behaviors – and in countless other ways – we persist in our efforts to confine our metaphorical demons to the shadows.

Unexplainable

Unexplainable

Listen to Unexplainable

“Unexplainable” guides its audience to the frontier of human knowledge – and then ventures beyond. Hosted by Noam Hassenfeld, alongside a talented group of journalists including Byrd Pinkerton, Meradith Hoddinott, and Mandy Nguyen, this program explores scientific enigmas, unresolved inquiries, and the insights gained from probing the unknown.

The Vanished Podcast

The Vanished Podcast

Listen to The Vanished Podcast

This podcast is an investigative audio series focused on disappearance cases. Each week, it looks into the circumstances surrounding a different missing person, offering more than just surface-level news coverage. The show’s presenter, Marissa Jones, provides listeners with unique conversations featuring relatives, acquaintances, investigators, and specialists.

Mysterious Radio: Paranormal, UFO & Lore Interviews

Mysterious Radio: Paranormal, UFO & Lore Interviews

Listen to Mysterious Radio: Paranormal, UFO & Lore Interviews

Mysterious Radio explores the extraordinary and unexplained. Join conversations with experts on paranormal events, extraterrestrial encounters, unsolved mysteries, conspiracies, cryptids, and other mind-bending phenomena. Prepare to challenge your understanding of reality!

Chameleon: Wild Boys

Chameleon: Wild Boys

Listen to Chameleon: Wild Boys

In the early 2000s, a pair of emaciated siblings appeared from the wild, recounting an astonishing tale of endurance. A tiny town in Canada welcomed them with open arms. However, there was a significant catch: the young men’s identities were not as they claimed.

Lore Podcast Review

Lore

Listen to Lore

This acclaimed audio series, which has also been adapted into television and literature, explores somber historical accounts. Each installment examines enigmatic beings, sorrowful occurrences, and peculiar locations that have left their mark on the annals of time. The show’s premise rests on the notion that reality can often surpass fiction in its capacity to terrify. Read our review of the Lore podcast.

Last Seen

Last Seen

Listen to Last Seen

“Last Seen” is a gripping investigative podcast that delves into the mysterious world of missing persons and unsolved disappearances. Each episode meticulously examines a different case, exploring the circumstances surrounding the vanishing, the impact on loved ones, and the ongoing efforts to uncover the truth.

Dark Histories

Dark Histories

Listen to Dark Histories

Biweekly tales exploring unresolved enigmas, inexplicable phenomena, perplexing historical crimes, hints of supernatural occurrences, and intriguing cultural oddities.

Nostalgic Mystery Radio

Nostalgic Mystery Radio

Listen to Nostalgic Mystery Radio

Classic audio detective dramas from a bygone era, revived for contemporary enthusiasts of vintage entertainment. The collection features iconic sleuths like Sherlock Holmes, Sam Spade, Philip Marlowe, and other renowned characters from radio’s golden age.

Missing in Alaska

Missing in Alaska

Listen to Missing in Alaska

“Missing in Alaska” investigates the 1972 vanishing of two U.S. Congressmen in Alaska’s skies. Despite an unprecedented search, the case went cold. Years later, a criminal’s bomb claim reignites interest. Journalist Jon Walczak’s quest for answers spans from desert to tundra, challenging the official ice theory and exploring potential foul play.

Mystery History Podcast

Mystery History Podcast

Listen to Mystery History Podcast

This audio series examines enigmatic historical events, covering a range of topics from clandestine plots and unsolved crimes to paranormal phenomena and various other intriguing subjects. The hosts infuse their exploration with understated wit as they navigate through these perplexing tales from the past.

1001 Heroes, Legends, Histories & Mysteries Podcast

1001 Heroes, Legends, Histories & Mysteries Podcast

Listen to 1001 Heroes, Legends, Histories & Mysteries Podcast

History Unleashed: A dynamic podcast exploring diverse historical narratives. Host Jon Hagadorn presents concise, well-researched episodes on hidden treasures, unresolved enigmas, peculiar occurrences, wartime accounts, notable figures, catastrophes, folklore, and cinematic origins.

Deadly Manners

Deadly Manners

Listen to Deadly Manners

“Deadly Manners” is a macabre comedic whodunit set in 1954. During the Billings’ lavish soiree, a blizzard traps the eccentric attendees in a mansion. As guests begin to die mysteriously, survivors must unmask the killer or become the next victim in this 10-part series.

Finding Drago | Finding Desperado

Finding Drago | Finding Desperado

Listen to Finding Drago | Finding Desperado

“Finding Desperado” is a fresh investigative podcast led by humorists Alexei Toliopoulos and Cameron James, the duo behind the buzzworthy 2019 podcast “Unraveling Drago.” As Australia’s foremost (and sole) pop culture sleuths, Alexei and Cameron have stumbled upon a peculiar Guinness World Record from 2005. This accolade, attributed to a mysterious European noble, is one they suspect to be fraudulent.

The Fourth Ambit

The Fourth Ambit

Listen to Fourth Ambit

“The Fourth Ambit” is a futuristic audio thriller set in a world dominated by virtual realms and corporations. Gilles, a researcher, is thrust into a dangerous conspiracy involving multiple layers of digital reality. As he goes deeper, he uncovers the possibility of an AI-controlled fourth layer. This nine-part series offers an immersive experience with rich storytelling, advanced audio production, and stellar performances.

Mysterious Universe

Mysterious Universe

Listen to Mysterious Universe

Consistently fascinating and frequently hilarious, tune in with hosts Aaron Wright and Benjamin Grundy as they explore the latest trends in futurology, bizarre science, consciousness studies, alternative history, cryptozoology, UFO phenomena, and new-age oddities.

The White Vault

The White Vault

Listen to The White Vault

Dive into the depths of global terror with the audio drama podcast The White Vault. Track the documented journey of a repair team dispatched to Outpost Frosted in the expansive white wilderness of Svalbard and uncover the secrets lurking beneath the ice.

The Left Right Game

The Left Right Game

Listen to The Left Right Game

Tessa Thompson plays an ambitious young journalist striving to establish her reputation by trailing a group of paranormal investigators fascinated by an apparently innocuous hobby called the Left/Right Game. Their adventure leads them into a supernatural realm that proves too perilous for her and the other expedition members to endure.

Locations Unknown

Locations Unknown

Listen to Locations Unknown

Join the exhilarating adventure with ‘Locations Unknown,’ an engaging podcast that delves into the mysterious and unsolved cases that haunt our country’s untouched wilderness areas.

Stuff They Don’t Want You To Know

Stuff They Don’t Want You To Know

Listen to Stuff They Don’t Want You To Know

From UFO sightings to psychic abilities and government conspiracies, history is filled with enigmatic events.

Wind of Change

Wind of Change

Listen to Wind of Change

It’s 1990. The Berlin Wall has just fallen. The Soviet Union is nearing collapse. The anthem of the revolution is “Wind of Change,” a metal ballad by the Scorpions that became one of the best-selling songs of all time. Decades later, journalist Patrick Radden Keefe stumbled upon a rumor: the song wasn’t composed by the Scorpions, but by the CIA.

The Confessionals

The Confessionals

Listen to The Confessionals

Reality often surpasses fiction in its strangeness. The Confessionals Podcast goes into the true accounts of those who have encountered unexplained phenomena. In this interview-based podcast, host Tony Merkel engages in conversations with ordinary people who recount their extraordinary experiences with the unexplainable and with dedicated researchers exploring the realms of high strangeness.

Paranormal Mysteries

Paranormal Mysteries

Listen to Paranormal Mysteries

There are inexplicable mysteries in this world. Every week, listeners are invited on a journey into the realm of high strangeness, exploring hauntings, bizarre creatures, extraterrestrials, folklore, missing persons, and numerous other supernatural phenomena. The unknown beckons.

Do you know of another podcast about mysteries that you think should be on this list? Let me know.

You might also like these lists of podcasts to discover:



Discover the world’s best podcasts in your inbox! (12,000+ readers ❤️ it!)

Subscribe and get Find That Pod in your email inbox. It’s FREE. No spam. 1 Email per week. Unsubscribe anytime.

This will close in 0 seconds