If you’re a fan of the thrilling tales spun by Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark on My Favorite Murder, then you’re in for a treat! Here are some similar podcasts that might just tickle your true crime fancy.
Criminal
Criminal is a rollercoaster ride through tales of mischief, misfortune, and those stuck in the sticky web of crime. Criminal blasted onto the scene in January 2014, and ever since it’s been serving up fresh episodes of intrigue and suspense every other Friday. It’s like clockwork but way more exciting if you’re into criminal stories, that is.
Criminal is a global sensation, making waves in the podcasting universe. It’s been hailed as one of the best by Time, The Atlantic, Rolling Stone, Cosmopolitan, USA Today, and Wired. Talk about a superstar!
Buckle up, crime enthusiasts. It’s time to dive into the captivating world of Criminal.
Small Town Murder
Get ready for a wild ride with two hilarious comedians as they delve into the heart of small-town life, uncovering its quirks, charm, and… a murder mystery? That’s right! They’re turning tragedy into comedy, one small town at a time.
Armed with in-depth research and a knack for finding the funny in the unfathomable, this dynamic duo takes a comedic spin on the darkest of tales. It’s a unique blend of humour and horror that you won’t want to miss! So mark your calendars because it’s about to get hilariously grim.
Sword and Scale
Sword and Scale is a podcast that meticulously explores the grim realities of criminal activity and the corresponding responses from the criminal justice system. The inaugural episode was launched on January 1st, 2014, and since then, it has consistently presented narratives involving murder, abduction, rape, and other forms of crime that defy conventional understanding.
This show represents the quintessence of true crime, utilizing raw, uncensored audio to narrate the stories. It incorporates a wide range of sources, from emergency 911 calls and court testimonies to interviews with victims and, on occasion, the perpetrators themselves.
Narrated from the perspective of the average individual, Sword and Scale transcends the superficiality of news clips and sensationalist headlines. It compels the audience to confront a challenging question: Are we fundamentally different from those we label as ‘them,’ or do we share more similarities than we care to admit?
Casefile
Launched in 2016, Casefile has since blossomed into a globally recognized, award-winning true crime podcast boasting a dedicated team across various continents. This podcast doesn’t just skim the surface. Each episode plunges into the depths of both solved and unsolved cases worldwide, exploring the intricate details of the circumstances, the meticulous investigations, and the riveting trials.
With a staggering number of downloads in the hundreds of millions, Casefile consistently secures a top spot in podcast rankings. Esteemed publications like Rolling Stone and Time magazine have hailed it as an essential listening experience.
Minds of Madness
Ever wondered what makes the guy next door suddenly do the unimaginable? Welcome to The Minds of Madness, a true crime podcast that’s as thrilling as it is thought-provoking. Broadcasting straight out of Toronto, Canada, this award-winning show is about to become your new obsession!
Each episode takes you on a rollercoaster ride through some of the most jaw-dropping crimes ever committed. But hold on tight because it’s not just about the crime – it’s about the ripple effect of chaos that follows.
Get ready to hear from those who’ve lived to tell the tale, the survivors of homicide, sharing their heart-wrenching stories. The show also brings in the pros – the forensic whizzes and psychology gurus – to give you a peek into the darker corners of the human mind.
Amidst the horror and heartbreak, you’ll find stories of incredible resilience and hope. Because even in the darkest times, the human spirit shines through.
Morbid
The Morbid Podcast, produced by Wondery, is a gripping and chilling exploration of true crime stories. Hosted by autopsy technician Alaina Urquhart-White and hairstylist Ashleigh Kelley, the podcast delves deep into the darkest corners of human nature, recounting horrifying tales of murder, serial killers, and mysteries. With their unique blend of empathy, humour, and thorough research, Alaina and Ashleigh bring these macabre stories to life, providing listeners with a captivating and spine-tingling experience.
Each episode of The Morbid Podcast takes listeners on a haunting journey, unravelling the details and motivations behind infamous crimes. Just be warned, some explorations span multiple podcast episodes, such as the recent 5-part exploration of H.H. Holmes.
A fantastic component of this podcast is that the hosts have begun running “Listener Tales” episodes inviting podcast fans to submit their own Morbid stories of crime.
Crime Junkie
Are you a crime junkie with a true-crime-shaped hole in your heart that nothing can fill? You’ve even resorted to deep internet searches on potential friends and lovers, hoping for some juicy secrets. Let’s face it. You’re convinced you missed your true calling as a detective. The struggle is real, but fear not, for The Morbid Podcast from Wondery is here to save the day and fill that crime-shaped void in your life!
Join hosts Alaina Urquhart-White and Ashleigh Kelley as they dive headfirst into the darkest corners of human nature. With their killer blend of empathy, humour, and extensive research, they bring the most spine-chilling true crime stories to life.
Each episode takes you on a twisted journey, unravelling the motives behind heinous crimes, examining the forensic evidence, and shining a light on these cases’ impact on the victims and their families. As an aside, why is it that two witty ladies host all the top true crime podcasts? An exciting mystery to be explored for sure.
Lore
Lore is a tightly produced podcast designed to walk you through some of the creepiest corners of history! This award-winning, critically-acclaimed podcast is here to expose the dark underbelly of our world, bringing you spine-tingling tales of terrifying creatures, chilling individuals, and haunting locations that’ll make your nightmares blush. It falls a bit less into the true crime category of podcast than some of the other shows on this list but still has its fair share of amazing episodes detailing some true crime doozies.
In each episode, you’ll be treated to a modern campfire experience, immersing yourself in the shadows of history as bizarre and bone-chilling tales unfold. With a crazy 41,000 5-star reviews on Apple Podcasts and over 415 million listens you know you’re in for a terrifyingly good time.
Up and Vanished
The Up and Vanished podcast is a gripping investigative series that unravels cold cases and missing person mysteries. Hosted by filmmaker Payne Lindsey, the podcast unravels unsolved disappearances, shedding light on forgotten cases and seeking justice for the victims and their families. With meticulous research, interviews, and compelling storytelling, Up and Vanished takes listeners on a suspenseful journey, exploring the facts, suspects, and potential leads surrounding each case.
Whether you’re a true crime enthusiast or simply intrigued by unsolved mysteries, this podcast will captivate you and leave you pondering the chilling possibilities behind each disappearance.
Discover the best episodes of the My Favorite Murder podcast.
Read our review of the My Favorite Murder podcast.