If you’ve worn out your earbuds binging “Normal Gossip” and find yourself desperately craving more juicy, low-stakes drama about complete strangers, you’re not alone. There’s something irresistibly addictive about eavesdropping on the messy lives of anonymous people.
For those who have finished every episode of Kelsey McKinney’s masterclass in harmless hearsay and now face the gaping void between new releases, I’ve compiled a treasure trove of podcasts that capture that same perfect blend of riveting everyday chaos, storytelling brilliance, and the comforting reminder that everyone else’s life is at least as wonderfully weird as yours.
Here are some podcasts that are similar to “Normal Gossip”.
Petty Crimes
Petty Crimes is a weekly comedy podcast where friends Ceara Jane O’Sullivan and Griff Stark-Ennis hilariously apply true crime analysis to minor everyday arguments. Perfect for fans of comedy and true crime, this podcast turns small squabbles into addictive and funny cases.
The Dating Detectives
Listen to The Dating Detectives
Discover the dark side of dating with Mackenzie Fultz, a professional Private Investigator, and Hanna Anderson, a Comedian, as they co-host this weekly podcast. They investigate the stories of liars, cheaters, and con men who have inflicted emotional damage and destroyed trust in the dating scene. By revealing the lies, scams, and manipulations of these deceivers, they aim to illuminate the red flags to watch for in the chaotic landscape of dating apps.
Diss and Tell
Diss and Tell, a weekly podcast from Wondery hosted by comedians Sydney Battle and Matt Bellassai, dissects the most iconic celebrity feuds. They explore the rumors and accusations to reveal the full story.
The Big Flop
Join TikTok superstar Misha Brown on Wondery’s The Big Flop, a weekly podcast diving into history’s biggest flops and fiascos. With hilarious guests, they dissect moments like Fyre Fest and Taylor Swift in Cats, exploring the bad ideas behind them.
The Break Up Break Down
Listen to The Break Up Break Down
For relationships that feel like true crime, Abby is on the case! This podcast delves into the difficulties of breaking up, especially when social media amplifies the drama. Through conversations with couples and individuals, we uncover the reasons behind their splits, the efforts they made, and the valuable takeaways, all while sharing moments of humor and empathy.
Sounds Like A Cult
Sounds Like A Cult, the iHeart Radio Award-winning podcast, explores the “cultish” aspects of various cultural phenomena each week. From SoulCycle to Disney Adults and even Instagram, they analyze fanatical groups to determine if they truly qualify as cults.
Everybody Has a Secret
Listen to Everyboy Has a Secret
Tune in as Annabelle Lee and Louis Hanson reveal the unbelievable, private secrets shared by their listeners.
Bad Dates
Get ready for more hilarious dating horror stories on BAD DATES, from the SmartLess team! Hosted by Joel Kim Booster (Loot, Fire Island, Netflix), the podcast features him and his comedian friends sharing their most unforgettable dating disasters, the kind we can all unfortunately relate to. Expect big laughs, a touch of sadness, and lots of cringe.
Everyone Has An Ex
Narrated by Georgia Love, this documentary series, Everyone Has An Ex, shares surprising and personal stories of past relationships. The good, the bad, and everything in between.
Call Your Girlfriend
Listen to Call Your Girlfriend
This podcast is for best friends living far apart, co-hosted by BFFs Ann Friedman and Aminatou Sow, and produced by Gina Delvac.
Something Was Wrong
Something Was Wrong is an award-winning docuseries about survivors of crime and abuse: their discoveries, trauma, and recovery.
Tales of Taboo
Tales of Taboo, with Ali Weiss, investigates and celebrates what happens behind closed doors through anonymous listener stories of scandals, struggles, and liberation.
Perfect Person
Miles Bonsignore presents a flawless call-in advice show where he answers your calls, resolves your dilemmas, and assists you in achieving perfection.
The Juice with Solomon Georgio
Listen to The Juice with Solomon Georgio
On The Juice, comedian Solomon Georgio dishes out the wildest everyday gossip he’s collected from funny friends and listeners. Expect low-stakes, high-petty stories like workplace weirdness and unexpected romances.
Two Hot Takes
Morgan Absher and her co-hosts scour Reddit, listener mail, and the web to deliver their strong opinions on the most engaging dating, relationship, life, and AITA narratives. Read our review of Two Hot Takes and discover the best episodes of Two Hot Takes.
Wheel of Misfortune
Join Alison Spittle and co-host Kerry Katona as they and their listeners recount their funniest and most embarrassing moments, the bad experiences that are actually good entertainment. Hear from celebrity guests, comedians, and former co-host Fern Brady. Binge all episodes now!
Read our review of Normal Gossip
Discover the best episodes of Normal Gossip