For the loyal listeners of “Scared to Death,” the allure of spine-tingling narratives and eerie encounters is undeniable. This gripping podcast has carved a niche for itself, drawing those with an insatiable appetite for the macabre and mysterious. If you find yourself yearning for more chilling tales once the credits roll, you’re in for a treat. In this article, I’ve pulled together a list of podcasts that resonate with the same haunting energy and spine-chilling allure as “Scared to Death.”
Two Girls One Ghost
Dive in with hosts Corinne Vien and Sabrina Deana-Roga, best friends hailing from opposite coasts, united by an undeniably fervent fascination with the eerie, uncanny, and unnerving. Drawing from in-depth research and stories contributed by listeners, they venture into tales of the supernatural. However, a word to the wise: “Two Girls One Ghost” holds the reputation of being America’s most haunted podcast.
Creepy
Brought to you by Jon Grilz, this compilation features some of the most renowned and unsettling creepypastas and urban legends known globally. A word of caution to listeners: tread lightly, as some content may be disconcerting.
And That’s Why We Drink
Listen to And That’s Why We Drink
When true crime collides with the supernatural! Sip on your wine or indulge in a milkshake, and join us each Sunday for spine-tingling ghostly tales intertwined with hair-raising real crime narratives. Given the frightening realities of our world, it’s no wonder we raise our glasses!
The Box of Oddities
Honored with a Webby Award, “Box of Oddities” is a podcast voyage into the curious and enigmatic corners of our universe. It spans discussions on outlandish medical anomalies, unresolved enigmas, supernatural events, and peculiar global customs.
Let’s Not Meet: A True Horror Podcast
Listen to Let’s Not Meet: A True Horror Podcast
Genuine tales of horror penned by survivors who lived to tell the tale. Experience firsthand accounts as they’re brought to life and woven into a tapestry of terror and tension by Andy Tate.
The NoSleep Podcast
The NoSleep Podcast stands as a multi-award celebrated anthology, presenting original horror narratives, accentuated by deeply immersive musical backdrops to amplify the chills.
Lore
“Lore,” now extended into a TV series and book collection, is a podcast released every other week that dives deep into shadowy historical narratives. Each installment unveils tales of enigmatic beings, heart-wrenching incidents, and curious locales that history has archived. Often, reality proves to be more chilling than any tale of make-believe.
Astonishing Legends
Our world brims with mysteries that often surpass the boundaries of our usual comfort. Occasionally, we encounter these enigmatic moments, many times oblivious to their presence. When we do recognize them, we tend to retreat to our routine, everyday lives. But what if, instead of merely acknowledging these uncertainties, we delved into them, engaging with those who have insights into the unseen?
Snap Judgment Presents: Spooked
Listen to Snap Judgment Presents: Spooked
“Spooked” showcases real accounts of supernatural encounters, narrated by individuals still grappling with their own disbelief. Prepare to be unnerved.
Spooky Spouses
Dive into the spectral realm with “Ghosts n’ Stuff,” helmed by Lindsey and Jordan Reed. Delve into a myriad of subjects, from sightings of elusive cryptids and sensational paranormal headlines to the mysteries of time-traveling crystals, a forsaken ship overrun by rats, and even tales about their dog.
Monsters Among Us
“Monsters Among Us” is an anthology of firsthand paranormal encounters, presented through authentic audio recordings from those who experienced them. Host Derek Hayes takes you on a chilling journey, exploring subjects from ghosts and UFOs to cryptid creatures like Bigfoot. Dive into the eerie and unknown with Derek’s curated tales.
Disquietude
“Disquietude” is a podcast that delves into the unnerving fragments of internet history and real-life tales of “True Horror” shared by those who’ve lived them. Immerse yourself in stories that echo in the quiet of the night.
Radio Rental
Unearth true tales of horror, from eerie crimes to supernatural events, all set within the fictional backdrop of the ’80s-themed Radio Rental store. Managed by the quirky shopkeeper, Terry Carnation (portrayed by Rainn Wilson), this unique horror brand seamlessly merges fact with fiction, employing gripping documentary-style narratives complemented by a touch of humor.
Supernatural with Ashley Flowers
Listen to Supernatural with Ashley Flowers
While many mysteries can be unraveled by examining the facts, some truths are nestled in the enigmatic. Step into the world of true crime’s oddest events and dissect every conceivable explanation, no matter how uncanny or extraordinary.
Chilling Tales for Dark Nights
Listen to Chilling Tales for Dark Nights
“Chilling Tales for Dark Nights” is a weekly horror anthology podcast. Each episode unveils a series of spine-tingling stories penned by skilled authors, vividly narrated by professional voice actors, and heightened with evocative SFX and music.
Scream!
A horror movie podcast that transformed from heated movie debates into spirited, yet informative discussions. Presented by Ash & Alaina from “Morbid: A True Crime Podcast” and Caleb from “Horror Soup.” Differences in opinion? All part of the charm.
Read our review of the Scared to Death podcast
Discover the best episodes of Scared to Death